Maynard's Cafe Menu

If you're ever in the Margate City area, you absolutely can't miss out on the Maynard's Cafe Menu. Located at 9306 Amherst Ave, this cozy spot offers a mix of classic comfort food and innovative dishes that’ll make you feel right at home. Whether you're stopping by for a quick bite or planning to enjoy a long, relaxed meal, there’s something on the menu for everyone.

From fresh seafood to hearty sandwiches, each dish is crafted with care and packed with flavor. You’ll find everything from crisp salads to delicious pasta options, all prepared with high-quality ingredients. Don’t forget to try their signature cocktails, which pair perfectly with any of the menu items. The atmosphere is laid-back yet vibrant, making it the ideal place for a casual dinner or catching up with friends.

Whether you're a local or just visiting, the Maynard's Cafe Menu is sure to satisfy your cravings with its variety and taste.

Soup & Salads

Clam Chowder
Manhattan, New England, OR AC (mix of both)
US$6.00
Garden Salad
US$8.00
Caesar Salad
US$7.50
Amherst Salad
spinach, goat cheese, red onion, bacon pieces and our house balsamic vinaigrette
US$10.00
Diva Salad
mixed greens, tomatoes, red onions, croutons and fresh mozzarella topped with jumbo lump crab meat, shrimp and our house vinaigrette
US$15.00
Lucy Salad
mixed greens, tomatoes, bleu cheese crumbles, craisins, toasted walnuts and our house vinaigrette
US$10.00
Portabella Salad
spinach, red onions, goat cheese, roasted red peppers, grilled portabella, house vinaigrette
US$10.00

Burgers

Build Your Own Burger
US$9.00
Maynard Burger
grilled taylor pork roll and american cheese
US$11.00
Big Bacon Bleu
smoked bacon and crumbled bleu cheese
US$11.00
The Shoe In
fried onions, mushrooms, swiss & bacon
US$12.00
The Boss
goat cheese, pickled red onions, bacon jam
US$12.00
Mountaineer
bacon jam, cheddar, house bbq sauce, and a fried onion ring
US$15.00
Black Bean
spicy house made black bean patty topped with chipotle mayo and salsa cruda
US$10.00

Munchies

Steamers
plain, red, OR white
US$11.50
Mussels
red or white
US$11.50
Clams Casino
chopped clams, onion, bacon and peppers
US$11.50
Shrimp
coconut, fried OR buffalo
US$11.00
Crab Fritters
mini homemade jumbo lump crab cakes breaded & fried served with cocktail sauce
US$11.50
Mozzarella Sticks
US$7.00
Chicken Fingers and Fries
US$8.00
Onion Rings
jumbo breaded with house seasoning
US$6.50
Avocado Dippers
fried avocado pieces served with ranch dipping sauce
US$8.00
Jalapeno Poppers
filled with cream cheese, served with raspberry dipping sauce
US$8.00
Philly Cheesesteak Empanadas
green peppers, onions, provolone cheese
US$8.00
Bavarian Pretzel
beer mustard and cheese sauce
US$10.00
Mac N' Cheese Bites
side of bbq
US$8.00

Raw Bar

Clams on the Half
*market price*
$
Oysters on the Half
*market price*
$
U-Peel Shrimp
old bay and lemon
US$11.50
Crab Cocktail
*market price*
$
Cold Seafood Sampler
oysters, clams, u-peel shrimp and crab cocktail *market price*
$

Wings & Tenders

Choose a Sauce
Mild (closer to medium) / Hot (like the devil) / Whiskey Teriyaki Chesapeake (butter, old bay) / Mango Habanero / Barbeque / Lola (sweet with heat) / Honey Mustard
$
8 Wings
US$9.00
16 Wings
US$16.00
24 Wings
US$24.00
1 lb. Tenders
US$10.00
2 lbs. Tenders
US$18.00
3 lbs. Tenders
US$26.00

Pizza

Small (12")
Red or White. Toppings additional.
US$8.00
Large (16")
Red or White. Toppings additional.
US$12.00
Veggie Toppings (Whole)
mushrooms, onions, green peppers, jalapenos, tomatoes, spinach
US$1.50
Meat Toppings (Whole)
pepperoni, bacon, sausage, ham, shaved steak meat, ground beef
US$2.50

Kiddos (10 and under)

Chicken Fingers and Fries
All kids' meals include a drink & scoop of ice cream
US$8.00
Sliders with Fries
All kids' meals include a drink & scoop of ice cream
US$8.00
Grilled Cheese with Chips
All kids' meals include a drink & scoop of ice cream
US$8.00
Fish Fingers with Fries
All kids' meals include a drink & scoop of ice cream
US$8.00
Linguini (plain, butter, or red)
All kids' meals include a drink & scoop of ice cream
US$8.00
Hot Dog with Fries
All kids' meals include a drink & scoop of ice cream
US$8.00

Sliders & Dogs

All American
american cheese, lettuce, tomato
US$10.00
Pulled Pork
bbq pulled pork, caramelized onions, side of slaw
US$11.00
Crabcake
our famous mini jumbo lump crab cake, lettuce, tomato, cocktail and tartar
US$16.00
Black Bean
mini spicy black bean patties, topped with chipotle mayo and salsa cruda
US$10.00
Hot Dogs
(2) all beef hot dogs. Toppings additional.
US$5.00

Tacos, Nachos, Dillas

Street Style Tacos
choice of chicken or beef w/ red onion, fresh cilantro, lime
US$8.00
Gringo Style Tacos
choice of chicken or beef w/ lettuce, tomato, red onions, cheese
US$9.00
Fish Tacos
crispy fried fish, cilantro crema, salsa cruda, fresh cilantro, lime
US$13.00
Shrimp Tacos
grilled shrimp, lettuce, pickled red onions, cilantro crema, lime
US$13.00
Mahi Tacos
lightly blackened mahi, pickled red onions, shredded red cabbage, lettuce, topped with chipotle mayo. side of salsa cruda
US$15.00
Nachos Grande
house made corn tortilla chips, cheese sauce, jalapenos, tomato, onion, sour cream, side of salsa
US$8.00
Garden Dilla
spinach, tomatoes, onions and smoked gouda served with salsa and sour cream
US$9.00
Quesadilla
tomato, onions, peppers and mozzarella served with salsa and sour cream
US$7.00
Smokin' Dilla
pulled pork, smokey house bbq, jalapenos, red onion, shredded cheddar
US$10.00

Fries & Tots

Plain
US$4.00
Shore
old bay, white cheese sauce, scallions
US$5.00
New England
brown gravy & cheese sauce
US$6.00
Loaded
cheese sauce, bacon, jalapenos
US$6.00
Buffalo
buffalo sauce, bleu cheese crumbles, scallions
US$5.50
Maryland
sautéed jumbo lump crab meat, old bay and garlic aioli
US$13.00
Sweet Potato Fries
side of raspberry sauce
US$7.00

Sandwiches (served with chips and pickes)

BLT
bacon, romaine, tomato, mayo
US$6.50
Grilled Cheese
white, wheat OR rye
US$5.00
Cheese Steak or Chicken Cheese Steak
US$9.00
The Chicken Troiano
grilled chicken topped with roasted red peppers and mozzarella on a toasted garlic bun
US$11.00
Chicken Caesar Wrap
US$9.00
Starlite Special Wrap
grilled chicken, tomato, sauteed spinach, smoked gouda cheese and balsamic drizzle
US$11.00
Napolean Portabella
grilled portabela, spinach, roasted red pepper, grilled onion, smoked mozzarella and a balsamic drizzle
US$10.00
Famous Roast Prime Rib Sandwich
provolone, au jus and a horseradish spread
US$12.50
Crab Cake Sandwich
our famous jumbo lump crab cake with lettuce and tomato *market price*
$
Fried Fish Sandwich
beer battered haddock with lettuce and tomato
US$10.50
Mahi Sandwich
lightly blackened mahi topped with lettuce, tomato, and chipotle mayo
US$12.00
The Beach House
grilled seasoned ribeye topped with smoked gouda and crispy onion straws served on a toasted garlic bun with a side of homemade smokey bbq sauce
US$14.50
Low Country Chicken
house-brined crispy fried chicken, bacon jam, pickles, and a side of slaw
US$11.00
The Stevie
italian sausage, peppers, onions, provolone
US$10.50

Entrees (available after 4pm)

Crab Cakes
our famous jumbo lump crab cakes served with a side of asparagus and homemade tartar or cocktail *market price*
$
Linguini with Clams or Mussels
red or white
US$18.00
Fish N' Chips
beer battered haddock, fries, and coleslaw
US$16.00
Fried Shrimp
breaded and golden fried gulf shrimp, fries and coleslaw
US$16.00
Blackened Mahi
lightly blackened mahi filet, cilantro rice, asparagus, fresh pineapple salsa
US$16.50
Summertime Pasta
linguini, roasted tomatoes, spinach, grilled chicken, garlic, lemon, white wine sauce
US$16.50
Ready to order? Kerbside pickup, delivery and dine-in are all available.